The Lusaka Manifesto of 1969 enforced Trade Sanctions which resulted in Sri Lanka losing close to 90 million British Pounds in foreign exchange from 1969 to 1971. At the same time, Pakistan was supplying the West with 70 million pounds of tea a year, of which 65 million pounds was cultivated in Bangladesh. However, during Bangladesh's struggle for freedom in 1971, Pakistan had to procure 15 million pounds of tea from Sri Lanka, having lost the cooperation of Bangladesh. Prices for Ceylon tea increased by 20% (per pound), in the weeks that followed, reducing the impact of the Lusaka Manifesto, multifold. Today, Ceylon Tea accounts for more than 11% of the island nation’s total exports for a valuation of more than $1.37 billion.
Why the history lesson? To emphasize the importance of sanctions, embargoes, why and how they are effective, and likely to affect you. When President Biden travels to India, it isn’t a vacation trip; it’s a strategic move in International relations & economics that could very well affect you, and the business you’re operating.
First and foremost, what are sanctions and embargoes? Is there a difference?
What are Sanctions?
Sanctions are decisions, impositions, and occasionally, bans/penalties levied on a country (or individuals belonging to a country). They have added weightage with the increasing focus on Anti-Money Laundering - companies that engage in international business are required to comply with global Sanctions Lists and are required to check for any people/organisations related to any Politically exposed Persons. Sanctions are levied by the UN, international regulatory bodies (OFAC, HMT) or countries (multilaterally or regionally) to protect international and national peace and security. A deterrent to free trade, sanctions serve as effective economic tools to safeguard international law and peace. As with anything with weight, it casts a shadow (the shadow being the multiple parallels drawn between sanctions & economic coercion especially when levied unilaterally, often a precursor to economic turmoil).
Sanctions are of various types, such as -
a. Economic Sanctions
If going to war with a nation that “funds and harbours terrorism” is too extreme, economic sanctions are a subtle (maybe not quite so subtle) way to combat undemocratic principles, autocratic regimes, breach of human rights. Economic sanctions are singular amongst sanctions in that they may be tiered by the severity of restriction.
- For example, a tariff is a kind of economic sanction that adds a surplus tax on the goods imported from a particular country or corporate entity. So, when there is a political or diplomatic skirmish of sorts between US and China, the tariff rates go up on the imported/exported goods to and from these countries. Or, when the United Kingdom shows solidarity towards Hong Kong’s pro-democracy movement, it raises its tariffs for China-based communication companies with offices and market share in the UK.
- Non-tariff Barriers or NTBs are restrictions on imported goods pertaining to licensing, manufacturing, packaging standards. It isn’t a tax, as much as a quality check requirement. When the Rana Plaza collapsed in the capital city of Bangladesh, exposing the poor living-working conditions of workers in the fast-fashion industry, NTBs were an effective tool. Fast-fashion brands like H&M, Uniqlo, Zara, etc., now have to account for standards in production, packaging, and manufacturing. They can’t import their goods from their suppliers in developing nations, unless they abide by these restrictions and operational standards.
- Asset seizures or freezes are the prevention of the transaction of assets owned by either an individual or a country. When reports surface that Sadam Hussein has pilfered UN funds intended for humanitarian relief and funneled them into his personal coffers, building lavish palaces, his assets get seized or frozen. There is no money coming in or out of Iraq. The President now has an X amount of money (liquid assets), little to no cooperation from his neighbouring nations or the UN, and an impoverished, unemployed, hostile population. History bears witness to how that story ended.
- Embargoes are a blanket prohibition on specific trade items with one or more countries, usually in aid of protecting international peace and security. For example, in an attempt to control violence and war, the European Commission has an embargo on the trade of arms and military technology to the Central African Republic.
b. Diplomatic Sanctions
Diplomatic sanctions are marked by systematic withdrawal or removal of embassies or cessation of diplomatic relations with a country. The impact of diplomatic sanctions can be immediate or the national representative recall can be phased over a period of time.
c. Military Sanctions
A more open, pro-active intervention of armed forces against the sanctioned country, military sanctions can be seen in 2 main forms -
- Targeted military strikes on specific regions to disarm impending conflict
- Arms embargoes, which allow milder actions such as limitations on arms procurement for a particular nation (eg. Iran, North Korea)
d. Sports Sanctions
These sanctions are marked by the refusal or prevention of a country’s teams from competing in international events. India hasn’t played a cricket match in Pakistan since the 26/11 attacks in 2008. Moreover, no cricket-playing nation has played in Pakistan since 2009. Pakistan, as a nation, has played cricket since its inception in 1947. However, there haven’t been any cricket matches played in Pakistan since 2009. Every “home-match” Pakistan has played has taken place in the UAE. Why is that? A terrorist attack on the visiting Sri. Lankan cricket team in 2009, made international teams put a blanket ban against playing in Pakistan. When the 2011 World Cup was hosted by the sub-continent, matches were not hosted in Pakistan. How does this matter? Pakistan lost millions in revenue and GDP as a fallout of the 2009 incident, which it earlier generated via hosting cricket matches, the ensuing tourism, and sponsorship for its national team.
e. Sanctions on Environment
While relatively new, Trade sanctions and regulations against an entity (corporate, individual, or government) that doesn’t comply with ESG regulations are the talk of the town with the EU’s new mandate on ESG Compliance.
What, then, is an embargo?
An Embargo is a method of enforcing a sanction. Like two tightly connected dominos, if one falls, the other isn’t far behind. Sanctions are imposed on specific transactions on specific goods/services with regards to specific entities. Embargoes, however, are a blanket prohibition on trade for anything with a country. So, when the UN restricted the trade of weapons and military technology with Iran in 2010, that was a sanction. While, when the UN restricted trade by land, air, and naval routes with Iraq in 1990, that was an embargo.
Every country either buys or sells arms, military technology, drugs (medicinal), food grains, supplies for armed forces, research, and a myriad other reasons. A trade sanction on any such country would mean that they won’t be able to buy or sell these (for lack of a better word) products. These products are essential in many ways to the protection of its territory, its GDP, its technological and economic advancement. If evidence surfaces that goods, services or money from trade is being used to facilitate undemocratic, criminal, or terrorist regimes, trade sanctions are an effective tool to bring such behavior to check.
A country that has been sanctioned can’t buy or sell arms, which in itself doesn’t sound too drastic. What’s the worst-case scenario? It can’t protect its territory, its GDP suffers, the regime changes because it can’t defend itself. A country that is under embargo, can’t buy or sell anything, including but not limited to food grains. What’s the worst-case scenario? Famine, food shortage & civil unrest are all plausible outcomes that we have seen before.
A sanction is like a benign slap on the wrist, albeit on a world stage. An embargo is like cutting someone off at the knees and crippling them. Seems too far-fetched?! The Soviet Union did crumble onto itself. Ceylon tea is world-renowned, Bangladeshi tea, not quite.
Do sanctions “work”?
Any economist/mathematician/statistician will tell you that a famine is not possible in a democracy. The agricultural yield of a democracy can be in the red, whether it is due to drought, flood, or other natural calamities. The prices of food grains and essentials can be skyrocketing due to government negligence, poor storage, riots, a pandemic, and several other reasons. But, a famine is not possible, because international trade is still possible. Will there be pilferage of the goods? Possibly. Will there be a disparity between the economic classes within the democracy? Certainly. Will the democracy go into global debt? Yes. Will the democracy starve to death? Absolutely not.
Because, the fundamental tenet of a democracy, is that the government is answerable to its public. Hungry masses do not make for voting-in-your-favour masses. A government that lets its people starve will not keep its place for long. It’s in a country’s best interest to keep trade relations open, developing, and fertile (no pun intended).
Sanctions “work”, much like Mexican standoffs work. You don’t want to be in one. However, 3.1 billion people of our global population of 7.1 billion live in autocratic or anocratic countries. Sanctions serve as strong control measures in such regions, aided in part by the country’s need to be self-reliant & self-dependent in the face of looming regulations/control measures.
Role of Sanctions Checks in Business Operations
As a business, the implications of Sanctions & Political Exposure have lasting impact. Let’s say you initiate a transaction with someone in a foreign country. Did you check if that entity or country is under sanction? How do you know that the transaction is safe and does not violate any sanctions or embargoes?
You risk violating a sanction or embargo if -
- A payment has been made from or to someone under sanction or embargo.
- You make a payment to someone who is a citizen of a sanctioned country. Even if the payment was made to an account in a different, unsanctioned country, it is still a violation.
- You make a payment, or trade goods/services. If the bank you make the payment with is sanctioned, it is a violation. If the airline, shipping vessels, ports used to transport the goods are subject to sanctions, it is a violation.
- If you have dealt with a non-sanctioned intermediary, but the ultimate recipient of your goods/service is sanctioned. Well, no prizes for guessing, you are in violation.
The next question, then, is what all sanctions must a business be aware of and how does one check whether a counterparty is associated with any sanctioned entity?
For a full list of the Sanctions that every business should be checking for, please refer to the list here. Checking whether the business and the promoters you're potentially engaging with are part of any of these Sanctions covers your primary groundwork. However, it is important to ensure that KMPs, connected parties & associate companies of your potential partner are also not on any of these Sanction Lists.
Keeping all this in mind and running a business can be quite a hassle. It is for this very purpose that we often place our trust in the experts in this domain. Having a Risk Assessment Officer as part of your team is fast becoming one of the best practices in the industry. It becomes critical to have someone who can identify such risks before you sign any dotted line, more so as you see your business expanding into international geographies. However, if you’re not sure that having an internal risk team is for you, SignalX Sanctions Check allows you to analyse if any potential business partner/vendor might be associated with a sanctioned individual/organisation. For more details, you can reach out to us here.
To know more about the Due Diligence Checks that you can execute on your counterparties and vendors to stay compliant with current laws, we recommend you read:
- 11 cursory checks that you can perform when onboarding vendors and partners.
- 5 due diligence checks you must execute on your vendors and partners.
SignalX is purpose-built to help you understand the credibility of the parties you are doing business with and helps you stay compliant with regulatory requirements / internal risk policies. You can run automated Sanctions checks & Due Diligence on any given target and their related parties on SignalX.ai. Give SignalX a try today and supercharge your due diligence programs.
Click here to schedule a Live Demo to learn more